A curious thesis

At Three Toed Sloth, a description of the Singularity we’ve already had:

The Singularity has happened; we call it “the industrial revolution” or “the long nineteenth century”. It was over by the close of 1918.

Exponential yet basically unpredictable growth of technology, rendering long-term extrapolation impossible (even when attempted by geniuses)? Check.

Massive, profoundly dis-orienting transformation in the life of humanity, extending to our ecology, mentality and social organization? Check.

Annihilation of the age-old constraints of space and time? Check.

Embrace of the fusion of humanity and machines? Check.

Creation of vast, inhuman distributed systems of information-processing, communication and control, “the coldest of all cold monsters”? Check; we call them “the self-regulating market system” and “modern bureaucracies” (public or private), and they treat men and women, even those whose minds and bodies instantiate them, like straw dogs.

An implacable drive on the part of those networks to expand, to entrain more and more of the world within their own sphere? Check. (“Drive” is the best I can do; words like “agenda” or “purpose” are too anthropomorphic, and fail to acknowledge the radical novely and strangeness of these assemblages, which are not even intelligent, as we experience intelligence, yet ceaselessly calculating.)

Why, then, since the Singularity is so plainly, even intrusively, visible in our past, does science fiction persist in placing a pale mirage of it in our future? Perhaps: the owl of Minerva flies at dusk; and we are in the late afternoon, fitfully dreaming of the half-glimpsed events of the day, waiting for the stars to come out.

I am a skeptic that the nerd rapture, the Singularity, will ever occur in the way imagined by its devotees. I’m also a skeptic of the Singularity we’ve already had–not that I doubt that it occurred, but I doubt whether it was half as inevitable or half as good as its proponents claim.

1 Comment

  1. Interesantă şi ipoteza pe care ai citat-o în postare, şi opinia ta faţă de ea. Dacă Singularitatea tehnologică viitoare este, prin definiţie, imposibil de imaginat, atunci probabil că tot ceea ce îşi pot imagina oamenii în privinţa ei – inclusiv susţinătorii ei – se va dovedi inadecvat.
    Toate cele bune.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s